Better Giving vs Self-hosted Stripe

Self-hosted Stripe donation form vs Better Giving

If you have developers on hand, building your own donation form on Stripe gives you full control, and Stripe charges no platform fee. Card rates apply, with 1.5% extra on international cards and a nonprofit discount on request. The work doesn't stop at launch, though. Your team hosts and updates the donation form, your nonprofit attests to PCI compliance every year, and you write and send every receipt yourself.

Better Giving gives you a hosted, branded donation form you embed with a copy-paste snippet. Stripe handles card data, we send tax receipts automatically, and all of our code is public on GitHub if you want to check it. You pay no platform fee while the optional donor donation to Better Giving stays on, and stock, DAF and IRA gifts work without adding other providers.

Self-hosted Stripe vs Better Giving, feature by feature

FeatureBetter GivingSelf-hosted Stripe
Platform fee0% with the optional donor donation on, or 1.5% flat if you turn it off1, 2None from Stripe. You pay for building and maintaining the donation form3
Payment processingThird-party card fees, which donors can choose to cover1, 42.9% + $0.30 per US card, plus 1.5% for international cards. ACH 0.8%, capped at $5. Nonprofit discount on request3, 5
Who runs it501(c)(3) nonprofit, EIN 87-37589396Your nonprofit, on Stripe, a payments company3
Endorsed the National Council of Nonprofits principles for ethical fundraisingYes7No7
Payout speedWithin 5 working days8First payout 7 to 14 days after your first payment, then on your schedule9
Yield on balanceJust over 3% on savings, variable10, 11No3
Built-in endowmentYes, the Sustainability Fund12, 11No3
Crypto, stock, DAF & IRAAll four in one donation form, no platform fee13, 1Stablecoin payments where Stripe supports them. Stock, DAF and IRA need other providers14, 3
Global fiscal sponsorshipYes, 2.9% per sponsored gift15, 1No5
AuctionsNo13Only if you build them3
Raffles & giveawaysNo13Only if you build them3
Open-source codeYes, the full stack is public16, 17Your own code, if you publish it3
More on Self-hosted Stripe
Build and maintenanceCopy-paste embed, Better Giving maintains it2, 13Your developers build, host and update the donation form18
PCI complianceStripe handles card data, PCI SAQ A13Your nonprofit attests every year. The scope depends on your integration18
Tax receiptsAutomatic branded receipts13You write and send donation receipts yourself3
Donor CRMDonor records with CSV and API export13No donor management built in3

Not listed means we found no mention on that platform's public pricing or product pages. Small numbers link to each source.

What a self-hosted Stripe donation form takes

Your developers build, host and update the donation form. Your nonprofit attests to PCI compliance every year, writes and sends donation receipts, and handles stock, DAF and IRA gifts through other providers. Stripe charges card fees, with a nonprofit discount on request.

When self-hosting on Stripe is the better choice

Self-hosting fits a nonprofit with developers on staff that wants full control of its checkout code and mainly takes card and bank gifts.

Should you choose Self-hosted Stripe or Better Giving?

Self-hosted Stripe suits a nonprofit with developers on staff that wants full control of its checkout code and only needs card and bank gifts.

Better Giving suits a nonprofit that wants a hosted donation form it can embed in minutes, with stock, DAF, IRA and crypto gifts, automatic tax receipts and PCI handled by Stripe at SAQ A.

Self-hosted Stripe vs Better Giving FAQs

Laira celebrating

Getting started with Better Giving