Better Giving vs Givebutter

Givebutter alternative, the same free model with a 1.5% fallback

Givebutter includes a lot in its free plan. Silent auctions, raffles, events and a CRM with unlimited contacts all come included, payouts land in 2 to 3 business days, and Givebutter Wallet pays 2.5% APY rewards. If events drive your year, Givebutter fits well. It stays free by asking donors for an optional tip, and if you switch those off you pay a flat 3% plus card processing.

Better Giving uses the same model with a smaller fallback. If you turn the optional donor donation off, the fee is 1.5%, half of Givebutter's. Our donation form also takes stock, IRA and crypto directly, where Givebutter admins can only record stock by hand, and money in savings earns a little over 3%.

Givebutter vs Better Giving, feature by feature

FeatureBetter GivingGivebutter
Platform fee0% with the optional donor donation on, or 1.5% flat if you turn it off1, 20% with optional donor tips on, or 3% flat if you turn them off3
Payment processingThird-party card fees, which donors can choose to cover1, 4Covered by Givebutter or donors while the ask is on, 2.9% + $0.30 otherwise3
Who runs it501(c)(3) nonprofit, EIN 87-37589395Financial technology company6
Endorsed the National Council of Nonprofits principles for ethical fundraisingYes7No7
Payout speedWithin 5 working days82 to 3 business days by direct deposit3
Yield on balanceJust over 3% on savings, variable9, 102.5% APY rewards in Givebutter Wallet, variable6
Built-in endowmentYes, the Sustainability Fund11, 10Not listed3
Crypto, stock, DAF & IRAAll four in one donation form, no platform fee12, 1DAF gifts. Admins can only record stock by hand. Crypto and IRA not listed3, 13
Global fiscal sponsorshipYes, 2.9% per sponsored gift14, 1Not listed3
AuctionsNo12Yes, silent auctions3
Raffles & giveawaysNo12Yes, raffle tickets15
Open-source codeYes, the full stack is public16, 17Not listed3
More on Givebutter
Donor CRMDonor records with CSV and API export12Yes, free CRM with unlimited contacts3
Monthly cost$01$0. Givebutter Plus from $29 a month3
Events & ticketingNo12Yes, virtual, in-person and hybrid3

Not listed means we found no mention on that platform's public pricing or product pages. Small numbers link to each source.

Givebutter fees compared

Givebutter charges no platform fee while optional donor tips stay on. Better Giving charges none while the optional donor donation stays on. If you turn them off, Givebutter charges a flat 3% plus card processing, and Better Giving charges a flat 1.5%. Givebutter Plus starts at $29 a month, and Better Giving has no paid tier.

Interest on your balance, Givebutter Wallet vs Better Giving savings

Givebutter Wallet pays 2.5% APY rewards. Better Giving savings earn a little over 3%, are FDIC-insured and carry no market risk. Both rates can change. As a rule of thumb, every half point on a $50,000 balance is worth $250 a year.

When Givebutter is the better choice

Givebutter fits a nonprofit whose year revolves around galas, silent auctions, raffles and ticketed events, and wants a free CRM in the same place. Better Giving doesn't offer auctions, raffles or ticketing today.

Should you choose Givebutter or Better Giving?

Givebutter suits a nonprofit that wants free events, auctions, raffles, a CRM and fast payouts in one place.

Better Giving suits a nonprofit that wants stock, IRA and crypto gifts in its donation form, a lower 1.5% fallback fee, an endowment fund or fiscal sponsorship.

Givebutter vs Better Giving FAQs

Laira celebrating

Getting started with Better Giving